The 7 Best Non-Mint Toothpastes, According To Reviewers

Whether you’re sensitive to mint toothpaste or just not a fan of the taste, there are plenty of other flavors out there that’ll make you look forward to brushing your teeth. The best non-mint toothpastes are available with and without fluoride, and they come in a range of flavors, including cinnamon, strawberry, citrus, and chocolate. And if you prefer unflavored toothpaste, there’s an option for you, too.

What To Look For In A Non-Mint Toothpaste

When shopping for mint-free toothpaste, there are a few things to keep in mind, depending on your preferences and sensitivities. First, the American Dental Association recommends fluoride in toothpaste, which strengthens tooth enamel and helps prevent decay. That being said, many non-mint toothpastes are actually designed for children and may have a lower fluoride content, so if you opt for a kids’ toothpaste, you may want to check that it has the expert-recommended minimum of at least 0.221% sodium fluoride or 0.76% sodium monofluorophosphate for optimal oral health. Of course, some people simply prefer to forego fluoride altogether, which is why I’ve included a few fluoride-free options on this list (just be sure to keep up on dentist visits and regular brushing to prevent tooth decay). Also, some toothpastes contain sodium lauryl sulfate (SLS) to create foam while you brush. SLS is generally considered quite safe, but if you’re sensitive to that ingredient or prefer SLS-free products, I’ve included non-foaming toothpastes below as well.

Beyond that, your choice comes down to which of these toothpaste flavors you love the most.

Shop The Best Non-Mint Toothpastes

In a hurry? These are the best non-mint toothpastes on Amazon:

1. This Fan-Favorite Cinnamon Toothpaste: Tom’s of Maine Whole Care Natural Toothpaste

2. This Highly Rated Strawberry Toothpaste: Crest Kid’s Strawberry Rush Fluoride Toothpaste

3. A Non-Foaming Flavorless Toothpaste: Squigle Tooth Builder Sensitive Toothpaste

4. A Natural Toothpaste That Comes In 4 Non-Mint Flavors: Dr. Sheffield’s Certified Natural Toothpaste

5. A Citrus Toothpaste With Lemon & Lime Flavors: Red Seal Lemon Toothpaste

6. A Gel Toothpaste That Comes In 3 Fruity Flavors: Tom’s of Maine Natural Children’s Fluoride Toothpaste

7. A Vanilla Toothpaste That Tastes Like Frosting: Tanner’s Tasty Paste Vanilla Bling Toothpaste

From fruity orange mango to vanilla and more, scroll on for seven non-mint toothpastes that you’ll love brushing with every day.

1. This Fan-Favorite Cinnamon Toothpaste

Ingredients:

• Contains 0.76% sodium monofluorophosphate
• Contains SLS

Why it’s great: Tom’s of Maine is a fan-favorite brand, and reviewers swear by this cinnamon clove toothpaste that’s earned a stellar 4.7-star overall and has over 9,000 reviews. The foamy toothpaste contains fluoride to help strengthen tooth enamel and naturally derived hydrated silicas to remove surface stains. Beyond that, the toothpaste contains no artificial colors, flavors, sweeteners, or preservatives, and it comes in a recyclable tube.

According to a fan: “I’m so glad I decided to give this a try! I’ve been using it a few months and I’m thrilled with how it has removed the tea and coffee stains from my teeth! I’ve tried a couple of flavors and love the cinnamon clove! It’s a little pricier than other brands, but worth it to me.”

2. This Highly Rated Strawberry Toothpaste

Ingredients:

• Contains 0.243% sodium fluoride
• Contains SLS

Why it’s great: Crest is one of the most well-known oral hygiene brands, and its strawberry toothpaste is a popular pick on Amazon with over 8,000 reviews and a 4.7-star overall rating. This foamy fluoride toothpaste helps strengthen tooth enamel, and although it’s marketed to children, it’s still suitable for adults since it has a fluoride content of 0.243%. The best part? One reviewer noted it tastes like “freshly crushed strawberries.”

According to a fan: “This toothpaste is amazing! It has a great flavor, and has a great texture.”

3. A Non-Foaming Flavorless Toothpaste

Ingredients:

• Does not contain fluoride or SLS

Why it’s great: If you prefer an unflavored toothpaste without foaminess, this toothpaste for sensitive teeth is a highly rated pick. It’s fluoride-free and contains no foaming agents, so it offers an ultra-mild brushing experience, and it’s also free of other potential irritants, like artificial colors and sweeteners. Plus, the addition of xylitol helps control plaque, so you’ll be doing favors for your oral health.

According to a fan: “This, in my opinion, is the best toothpaste for sensitive teeth. While a little pricy for some toothpaste, it works very well. And if you’re sensitive to mint flavors—- this will work well for you too! It’s unflavored! By far the best!!”

4. A Natural Toothpaste That Comes In 4 Non-Mint Flavors

Ingredients:

• Does not contain fluoride or SLS

Why it’s great: Dr. Sheffield’s Natural Toothpaste is a highly rated pick that comes in four non-mint flavors: chocolate, cinnamon, mixed berry, and strawberry banana. The toothpaste is certified by the Natural Products Association (NPA), which means it’s made of mostly natural ingredients, biodegradable, and is not tested on animals. The formula contains no fluoride or synthetic ingredients, including foaming agents, preservatives, artificial colors, flavors, or sweeteners. Plus, reviewers have raved about the flavors (especially chocolate). This toothpaste is a great option if you want a basic, non-fluoride toothpaste that’s less foamy than traditional toothpaste.

According to a fan: “Tastes just like chocolate cake! I was surprised to find chocolate toothpaste so wanted to try it for fun. So glad I did, I’m converted. There’s no mint or anything just tastes straight up chocolately.”

5. A Citrus Toothpaste With Lemon & Lime Flavors

Ingredients:

• Does not contain fluoride or SLS

Why it’s great: Looking for a refreshing and zesty citrus toothpaste? This option from Red Seal contains natural lemon and lime oils, and one reviewer wrote that it “tastes like a lemon drop.” The toothpaste contains no fluoride, colors, or foaming agent, and it comes in a two-pack.

According to a fan: “The Best Toothpaste Ever!!! After nearly a decade looking for a toothpaste that I actually like 100%, I finally found it.”

6. A Gel Toothpaste That Comes In 3 Fruity Flavors

Ingredients:

• Contains 0.76% sodium monofluorophosphate
• Contains SLS

Why it’s great: Tom’s of Maine offers even more fun flavors in their line of children’s toothpaste. You can choose from fruit, wild blueberry, or mango and orange flavors. Along with silica and calcium carbonate to gently clean teeth, the foaming toothpaste contains a fluoride percentage that’s considered adequate for adult teeth. Besides that, the toothpaste is free of artificial flavors, colors, and preservatives, and it comes in a recyclable tube.

According to a fan: “The overwhelming peppermint-oil content of so many "grown-up" toothpastes is so unpleasant it was actually deterring me from brushing and that's not good, so I tried this. No peppermint! Just a mild, pleasant fruity flavor which is much easier to tolerate and makes it easier to brush for the recommended time.”

7. A Vanilla Toothpaste That Tastes Like Frosting

Ingredients:

• Contains 0.243% sodium fluoride
• Does not contain SLS

Why it’s great: This vanilla toothpaste makes brushing your teeth a real treat — in fact, a few reviewers compared the flavor to vanilla frosting, with one fan writing, “This toothpaste is a magical work of art.” The tasty toothpaste contains fluoride, however, it doesn’t contain the SLS foaming agent, artificial color or flavors, and uses natural xylitol to sweeten.

According to a fan: “It’s tastes SO good - like vanilla icing but not in an overpowering way. No gross aftertaste and it doesn’t foam up much which I love.”

Study referenced:

Nayak, P.A., Nayak, U.A., Khandelwal, V. (2014). The effect of xylitol on dental caries and oral flora. Retrieved from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4232036/